three_treble_violins


Three Treble Violins.

On the left is an original model treble violin by Carleen Hutchins. The string length on this model is about 8 1/3 inches (211.6 mm). Even at that short span, the tension on the string, tuned to E 1330 Hz, is probably in the neighborhood of 500,000 psi. The material used for the string is carbon rocket wire, the strongest wire we have been able to find. Even so, the string is near to its breaking point.

The two models center and right are experimental models of mine. The principal difference between them and the original is their neck lengths. The middle treble has a string length of about 9 1/2 inches (241 mm), and the model on the right has a string length of 10 3/4 inches (273 mm). The easiest way to spot the differences is to compare the bridge positions of the three trebles and then the nut position (the nut is where the strings go into the peg box). For reference, the treble on the right uses the classical proportion for string length, so you can see how much the neck had to be shortened on the original design to use the rocket wire string.

The largest model is very comfortable to play, but at the moment only the smallest model has a full set of strings. We have already found a new space-age material for the string core that can withstand the incredible tension of the longest string length, which is somewhere over 750,000 psi, but adapting it to the requirements of a musical instrument string has proved to be a formidable challenge.

The greatly oversize f-holes on the original model were intended to control the air resonance of the body cavity to meet Schelleng's theories as closely as possible. We have since discovered that it takes such a large change in the f-hole area to make a small change in the air resonance that it is probably not worth the structural and acoustical consequences.

3_trebles_rear

Photos by Barry Perlus.

Updated May 27, 2008



Treble (Piccolo) Violin

The treble violin is in many ways the most troublesome of the new family due to its small size and the tremendous tension required for the top string. Yet it was the first member of the new family to be adopted as a solo instrument by several players who were willing to train themselves to cope with its extremely short string length. In Western Europe, Russia, and Asia, the treble is almost universally called the "piccolo" violin, in some ways a better name.

That this instrument exists at all is a tribute to its creators, who made a number of astute compromises in its design. Among the options rejected were a four-string violin tuned down a whole step, and a three-string instrument as described by Michael Praetorius. Ergonomic considerations dictated that a full-size scroll and a full-width neck be used for an adult player's hand, and the result is effective and not unattractive.

As the smallest and highest member of the new violin family (the soprano violin is the next lowest in pitch), the treble violin was designed to fulfill Henry Brant's request for a violin-type instrument that could effectively play to the highest notes of the piano. In fact, in the hands of a competent player it even can play above the piano's highest notes, a remarkable accomplishment.

The tiny treble violin presents formidable challenges to even the best players. Above third position, the short string length makes playing rapid chromatic passages quite difficult. The player must remove a finger from the note and move it away before putting the next finger down. It requires many hours of practice, and the result is all the more remarkable since many treble players must switch back and forth between it and their conventional violin. On the other hand, tremendous leaps are possible with just a flick of the wrist, and single and double-stopped trills may be accomplished over a range not possible on any other violin.

Only a few other instruments can play in this range, and they have severe limitations. The piccolo flute is shrill and piercing, and composers must write for it with deference. The piano in the top octave is very brittle and percussive, with lots of hammer noise and very little sustain to the notes. Tiny organ pipes sound like, well, tiny organ pipes. The piccolo violin, on the other hand, is the only instrument in the world that can play in the extended upper register and do so sweetly, with a full range of dynamics, expression, and all the bowing techniques available on traditional violins. The piccolo violin's potential is so remarkable that contemporary composers have not yet figured out how best to use it.

Last updated August 24, 2008